Place the hard-boiled eggs in cold water and peel the shells off. Cut the eggs in half lengthwise so they are stable.
Clean out the center yolks with a spoon into a shallow bowl. Use a fork and smash them until they are smooth.
Add the mayonnaise, pickle juice, dill pickle, green onion, dried mustard, salt, white pepper, and celery salt, to taste, then mix thoroughly until creamy and smooth. Taste and re-season if necessary.
Spoon the mixture back into the egg halves. Sprinkle tops with paprika. Enjoy.